Veronica first appears in this episode, where she is introduced as Trixie Tang's less popular, less pretty, slightly spasmatic friend. Even after Timmy Turner wishes himself popular, Veronica remains very suspicious of him, although Timmy then temporarily blinded her with his shiny white teeth.
Trixie, having found a new best friend at the mall (Timantha), tears up Veronica's picture, causing her to feel actual physical pain. She later encounters Chester and A.J. in the boy's bathroom, having accidentally walked into the wrong stall. At the end of the episode, her stare of contempt influences Trixie to reject Timmy Turner once again.
Veronica is seen at home in this episode, as is Veronica's Mom, although she appears off-screen. Veronica is shown to be jealous of Trixie's popularity and questions why she can't be like her(she types this while bonking a Trixie doll on the computer keyboard). While chatting with Trixie via instant messaging, Timmy spies on them from within their computers having wished himself into the Internet, where he learns that Veronica likes him with the "white hot intensity of a thousand suns", although Timmy is not satisfied and still prefers Trixie, regarding Veronica as crazy. Veronica also reveals that she literally wants to be Trixie, going as far as to wear a wig and scream at her parents to call her by that name. At the end of the episode, Veronica steals a love note from Timmy meant for Trixie, thinking it's for her, and finds it very romantic, although Timmy still rejects her and has Cosmo and Wanda click-and-drag Veronica into a nearby garbage can via computer.
Veronica is dressed as the ruby Jack-O-Bot, and is regulated to shining the "more precious emerald" Jack-O-Bot that Trixie went as. After Timmy's wish to make everything Real and Scary, Veronica and the other popular kids become real Jack-O-Bots, who merge into the Pumpkinator and threaten to destroy the entire Earth. After they are defeated, the popular kids are returned to normal, and Veronica is seen celebrating with the other children as candy rains from the sky due to a YugopotamianP-Bomb.
Veronica becomes the superhero "Hawk Gal" after Timmy wishes for everyone in the world to have superpowers. Veronica is considered the lamest of the superheroes, as her only ability is to fly at very limited speeds. She attempts to fight the Nega-Chin and his group of villains, but is easily defeated after Elmer, The Bouncing Boil, is knocked into her just as she finally shows up to the fight.
As this episode takes place during the same time as "A Wish Too Far!", Veronica remains blinded throughout most of the episode, although she insults Chester and A.J. after they come to the popular lunch table to confront Timmy.
After Timmy wishes to be able to read minds, he attempts to read Trixie's mind to see if she really likes him. She does not, but a quick read of Veronica's mind reveals that she does like Timmy, and is slightly jealous that he is talking to Trixie and not her.
She is only seen during the beginning of the episode. But in the mall she falls into a fountain with Timmy, and the water dissolves her clothes. When she realizes she's caught in her underwear, she screams and runs off. She is not seen for the rest of the episode, probably due to embarrassment.
Veronica is seen telling a joke at her lunch table about Timmy shortly before he comes over and forces her and the popular boys to leave, using You Doo Dolls, so that he can have alone time with Trixie.