After Cosmo, Wanda, and Timmy are taken to Fairy Court. Jorgen acts as the prosecutor. He asks Timmy if he would really use his godparents' magic just for selfish gain. Timmy soon starts to realize he has been doing this for the wrong reasons. When he apologizes and wants to make amends, the judge goes to clear him, however Jorgen threatens the judge with his wand to make him say Timmy is guilty. Timmy is then blasted back to his house and although all the party stuff is still around, he realizes it isn't worth it to be popular. After the fairy judge sees Timmy throwing away his popularity and regaining his real friends, he decides to clear Timmy. Jorgen tries to protest, but Wanda gives a fiery glare at him. Jorgen agrees to this under one condition. After Cosmo and Wanda reunite with Timmy, Jorgen appears and puts a boil on Timmy's face as punishment for being selfish.
After Cosmo unintentionally reveals the wish he and Wanda granted, Jorgen grabs both godparents by the shirt and scolds them for the mess they made. Because of the wish they granted, everyone on Earth is exactly the same and none of the godparents can find their godkids. As a result magical backup occurs. When one fairy explodes, Jorgen laughs at that before changing his tune and saying solemnly "Poor little fairy!".
Jorgen comes for the Fairy Godparent Inspection, however since Timmy's parents were assuming that Timmy had stolen stuff from the Wall 2 Wall Mart, Timmy's godparents were in danger of being sent back to the Fairy Academy. Jorgen immediately fails Cosmo and Wanda on happiness due to Timmy not smiling. When Timmy is taken to the police station, Cosmo and Wanda tried to stall Jorgen for as long as they can. When Jorgen watches the news he nearly fails Cosmo and Wanda on responsibility before Wanda declares she does not care about the inspection because Timmy needs their help. Jorgen decides to pass Timmy's godparents on responsibility but decides to relish in the only little time Timmy and his godparents have left before the inspection is done. Once Timmy's name is cleared, he and his godparents quickly make lots of wishes and that is enough to get Jorgen to change happiness from an F to an A and make wishes made an A too. Jorgen then warns Timmy to be more careful about where he shows and puts his stuff before taking most of Timmy's wishes with him.
After Timmy wishes that his life is like an action movie, Jorgen becomes the villain and tries to suck all the magic from the fairies, so he can become the most magical fairy in the universe. Timmy, with the help of Jorgen's cat, defeats Jorgen.
Jorgen appears as the judge of the Magical Duel between Timmy and Remy. After Juandissimo fails to get the ape to release Remy, Jorgen states Juandissimo is still sexy. In the second round, Jorgen makes Timmy and Remy swap turns after Timmy's attempts don't even get the man's attention away from the fire. After Timmy wins the Duel, Jorgen snaps his fingers and Juandissimo ceases to be Remy's godparent.
Jorgen want's to be Timmy's fairy godparent when Timmy wishes he were the most wanted kid on earth. Jorgen proves to be excellent at the Texas boot match when, despite his bulky size, he manges not to get hit in the butt with a shoe.
Jorgen appears as a guest on This is Your Wish. It reveals that Jorgen once was a five star general, but is no longer due to Cosmo. While training Cosmo, Cosmo unintentionally brought out Snowball who destroyed the area. Jorgen then made Cosmo do janitorial business forever, but Cosmo is shown trying to redeem himself on a few occasions. However each one ended in disaster. When Jorgen raged out of control, a tranquilizer dart hitted his butt, knocking him out.
After Crocker's fairy godparents were revealed in front of Dimmsdale(Timmy tried to stop this, but 1970's Cosmo still caused it to happen). 1970's Jorgen came to take them away and wipe the memories of all witnesses including Crocker himself. When Timmy tried to fix the mess he did not mean to create, the present day and 1970's Jorgens appear and tell Timmy he and his godparents are banned from coming back to March of 1972 due to the mess they made. 1970's Jorgen states they are allowed to visit other months of 1972 as long as it does not interfere with George McGovern's presidential election. The two Jorgens then blast Timmy and his godparents back to the present before they leave to do disco together.