| "All godchildren look the same."
This article is about the in-universe TV show. For the TV special, see Fairy Idol.
Fairy Idol is a special television broadcast event in Fairy World that only occurs when a fairy godparent quits doing their duties and a new magical entity must be chosen to fill in their position in an American Idol style contest. Any magical being can participate in this contest whether they are good or evil and whoever performs the best musical, dancing, or singing performance wins.
Winner of the contest in bold.
- Unnamed William Hung Fairy
- Tooth Fairy
- Lawn Gnomes
- Juandissimo Magnifico
- April Fool
- Cosmo & Wanda
The prize is to become the fairy godparent for the most miserable child they can find and that child is Chester.